HVCC (Home Valuation Code of Conduct) causes dysfunction… again

Yep, it’s happened again.  An appraiser working out of his area (only slightly) has confounded me with an appraisal.  This on a bank owned property I have listed.  The seller had it appraised on September 25 2009 (what, 4.5 months ago?) and it came it at $47,000.  I thought that was a bit high, and since the seller wanted to be aggressive, we took it on the market at $34,000.

New appraisal?  $28,000.

The appraiser discounted listings that sold 3 months ago by 5%, indicating he believes the market to be declining at an annual rate of around 20%.  That may be in his market area, but in the TAAR MLS, the 4 month average sale price trend is 3.07% to the positive.

Post to Twitter

Comments

  1. I had an appraiser call me a couple weeks ago from the Lansing area asking me how the market was in Elk Rapids and asked if I could run him some comps for him, since he did not have access to our board information.

    HOW is an appraiser that does not have access to information that is crucial to his determination able to compile an accurate report???? With all the red tape in the banking industry you would think this would be a no brainer.

  2. Hey, I like your site. I was wondering if you would do a review post of my product at http://www.publicdomainpayday.com

  3. The place has maintained a stabilized per capita income over the years and at most times the per capita income has been more than other places in the US.

  4. loans says:

    I want to thank the blogger very much not only for this post but also for his all previous efforts. I found http://www.nwmirealestate.com to be very interesting. I will be coming back to http://www.nwmirealestate.com for more information.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] HVCC (Home Valuation Code of Conduct) causes dysfunction… again – It is a shame what is going on with appraisers right now. They were a big part of the problem [...]